Tucked away up a hill in North Bethesda sits a church building that is the namesake for the thriving urban center that surrounds it, built centuries ago and consistently in use–until recently.
The Bethesda Presbyterian Church built the Bethesda Meeting House in 1820 at what is now 9400 Rockville Pike and named it after a healing pool in Jerusalem. About 40 years later, the church’s pastor Rev. Edward Cumpston petitioned for the area to take the well-known name of the church. In 1871, it did, and Bethesda was named.
After Bethesda Presbyterian switched locations in 1925, Temple Hill Baptist Church took over the site. Its pastor Rev. Phillip Buford, who lived on and maintained the property, died in February 2022. The congregation has dwindled and no longer meets regularly since Buford’s death, according to the Bethesda Historical Society.
The building has since been passed over to a board of four trustees: the pastor’s wife Eloise Buford, his niece Sheri Nasca, her husband Edward Nasca, and David Moyer, the executive director of the Maryland Bible Society.
Buford gave Sheri Nasca the authority to manage the property before his death; she lives in North Carolina. Attorney Thomas Schetelich has been designated to speak on behalf of the trustees.
The new owners don’t have a “realistic way right now to commit the amount of money it would take” to maintain the property, said Schetelich.
Inspectors have issued notices for lack of compliance with codes and, because it is part of Montgomery County’s Historic Preservation Plan, there is legislation prohibiting its neglect.
Now the sign that once welcomed congregants to the “Church that named Bethesda” has fallen, and the building is in disrepair. Meanwhile, the Bethesda Historical Society is looking at options to preserve it.
“We’re interested in figuring out a way to save an important part of our culture and our history in the town,” Hank Levine, the Bethesda Meeting House project lead, said.
Levine laid out several community-oriented possibilities for the property, including an office space for nonprofits or a meeting facility.
“People can have concerts, we can have an art gallery, it can be used by a new or struggling congregation as a church,” Levine added.
Another option is for a local private school, such as Stone Ridge School of the Sacred Heart or Rochambeau French International School, to use it as a campus or remote space, but Levine says neither one has expressed interest.
Renovations of this property will come with a hefty price tag, and the state is exploring options to provide assistance.
The most “legislator friendly” approach, according to State Delegate Marc Korman, is using the state capital budget to leverage some financial resources for the site.
“A lot of Bethesda is changing,” Korman said, “so having something like this that can represent Bethesda as it’s been historically could be very powerful for the community.”
A historic acquisition would likely take a combination of state and private resources all dedicated to the site’s preservation; the restoration of this property will be a multi-year project.
Levine said the process can’t begin without control of the property, and control won’t happen without the funds to acquire it.
“We are literally talking about the most important historic building in Bethesda, and it is literally sitting there falling apart,” Levine said.
Until a final decision is made to historically acquire the property, it will continue to do so.